When it comes to fast-casual sandwich chains, two of the biggest names that come to mind are Subway and Jersey Mike’s.
Both offer a similar type of product—customizable sandwiches with a focus on fresh ingredients—but the two brands differ in many aspects. From their menu offerings and preparation styles to their business models and customer experience, there are notable differences between the two chains. If you’re considering which one to visit or even which one to invest in as a franchisee, understanding these distinctions can help make your decision easier.
In this article, we’ll take a closer look at what sets Subway and Jersey Mike’s apart, comparing their operations, ingredients, pricing, and overall brand experience.
Menu And Ingredients
One of the most obvious differences between Subway and Jersey Mike’s is their approach to menu offerings and ingredients.
Both chains focus on serving sandwiches, but they have different styles of preparation and options available.
Subway’s Menu
Subway is known for its vast menu, which includes a wide variety of bread, meats, cheeses, vegetables, and sauces.
Customers can choose from several pre-designed sandwiches, or they can create their own custom sandwiches from the available ingredients. Subway’s menu has something for everyone, including options for vegetarians, gluten-free diets, and low-calorie preferences.
Key Features of Subway’s Menu:
Bread Options: Subway offers a wide range of bread types, including classic white, whole wheat, Italian, honey oat, and even a gluten-free option. These options are soft and squishy, appealing to customers who prefer a lighter sandwich experience.
Meats and Protein Options: Subway features a variety of deli meats, including turkey, roast beef, ham, tuna, and various others. The brand also offers grilled chicken, meatballs, and plant-based alternatives like the Veggie Delight.
Customizable Sauces and Toppings: Subway allows customers to choose from a range of sauces, including classic mayo, mustard, ranch, sweet onion sauce, and others. It also offers a generous selection of vegetables like lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and pickles, allowing for a high level of customization.
Healthy and Specialty Options: Subway has positioned itself as a healthier alternative to traditional fast food with its “Subway Fresh Fit” menu, which includes lower-calorie sandwiches and salads.
Jersey Mike’s Menu
Jersey Mike’s, on the other hand, takes a different approach to its menu offerings. While they still offer a variety of subs, they emphasize quality ingredients and a more “sub shop” experience, with a focus on freshly sliced meats and cheeses.
Key Features of Jersey Mike’s Menu:
Freshly Sliced Meats and Cheeses: One of the standout features of Jersey Mike’s is that they slice their meats and cheeses fresh for each sandwich, which gives the subs a unique and flavorful taste. The brand uses premium deli meats and cheeses, which are a step above what you might find at Subway.
Signature Subs: Jersey Mike’s is known for its signature subs, such as the #13 Italian sub (a combination of various deli meats, including ham, salami, and pepperoni), and the #7 Club Sub (with turkey, ham, and bacon). These specialty sandwiches are crafted with specific combinations of ingredients, making them a popular choice for customers looking for a hearty, flavorful sub.
Hot Subs and Grilled Options: While Subway mainly focuses on cold subs, Jersey Mike’s offers a range of hot subs as well.
They use a unique grilling process, where the meat and cheese are toasted together, creating a warm, melty sandwich experience. This gives the subs a different texture and flavor than the cold sandwiches at Subway.
Quality Bread: Jersey Mike’s is known for its hearty, thick sub rolls, which hold up well to the fresh ingredients and toppings. The bread is baked fresh daily in each store and has a slightly crunchy exterior with a soft interior.
Customization: While both Subway and Jersey Mike’s allow for customization, Jersey Mike’s places an emphasis on fresh ingredients and premium toppings. Their menu includes several signature options, but customers are still encouraged to create their own sandwiches with fresh veggies, meats, and cheeses.
Preparation and Serving Style
While both chains offer custom-made sandwiches, the way they prepare and serve their subs differs significantly. The preparation process at each restaurant plays a large role in the overall customer experience.
Subway’s Preparation Style
Subway’s preparation style is well-known for its “assembly-line” process. Customers move down the counter and select their ingredients as they go. Each employee behind the counter adds the ingredients in a step-by-step manner, assembling the sandwich in front of the customer. Once the sandwich is complete, it’s wrapped up and handed to the customer.
Features of Subway’s Preparation Process:
Assembly Line: Customers choose their bread, meat, cheese, and toppings as they move down the counter. This allows for a highly customized experience but can also be slower during peak hours.
Bread to Meat Ratio: Since Subway sandwiches feature a soft bread that often dominates the texture, many customers opt for the “Double Meat” or extra fillings to balance out the sandwich. However, the bread-to-meat ratio can sometimes be an issue for those who prefer more substantial fillings.
Focus on Freshness: Subway prides itself on the freshness of its ingredients, particularly its vegetables. The veggies are typically cut and prepped daily to maintain freshness.
Jersey Mike’s Preparation Style
Jersey Mike’s takes a more traditional, deli-style approach to sandwich preparation. The sandwiches are made with a focus on the quality and quantity of the ingredients, which are freshly sliced right in front of the customer. Jersey Mike’s also offers hot subs, where the ingredients are toasted together for a warm, flavorful finish.
Features of Jersey Mike’s Preparation Process:
Fresh Slicing: One of the key differences in the preparation process is that Jersey Mike’s slices all their meats and cheeses fresh for each sandwich. This results in a more flavorful and authentic taste than what you might find at Subway.
Sub Sandwich Warmth: Jersey Mike’s also offers the option of getting a sandwich grilled or toasted, which adds to the flavor and texture of the sandwich. The hot subs are made by grilling the meat and cheese to perfection, creating a gooey and warm sandwich.
More Attention to Meat and Cheese: While Subway offers a broad range of ingredients, Jersey Mike’s places a stronger emphasis on the quality of the meat and cheese. The premium deli meats used at Jersey Mike’s are a big selling point for customers who prioritize high-quality fillings.
Price Comparison
When it comes to pricing, both Subway and Jersey Mike’s are relatively affordable, but there are some differences between the two brands.
Generally speaking, Jersey Mike’s tends to be slightly more expensive than Subway due to its focus on premium ingredients and freshly sliced meats.
Subway’s Prices
Subway’s prices are considered to be competitive, with foot-long subs typically priced between $6 and $10. The chain’s focus on offering affordable meals makes it a popular option for budget-conscious consumers. Subway also offers a “Value Menu” with smaller sandwiches at lower price points, making it an even more affordable option for those who don’t want to spend much.
Jersey Mike’s Prices
Jersey Mike’s sandwiches are generally priced higher, with foot-long subs ranging from $8 to $12, depending on the location and ingredients. The premium quality of the meats and cheeses, along with the added cost of freshly sliced deli items, contributes to the higher prices. However, many customers feel the extra cost is justified by the quality of the sandwich and the overall dining experience.
The Dining Experience
While both Subway and Jersey Mike’s focus on providing fast, convenient service, the dining experience can vary greatly between the two chains.
Subway’s Dining Experience
Subway’s dining experience is quick and convenient, with many locations offering drive-thru services for on-the-go customers. The environment is casual, and the restaurant often focuses more on speed and efficiency than on ambiance.
Customers typically order at the counter, where the staff prepares the sandwich in front of them.
Jersey Mike’s Dining Experience
Jersey Mike’s offers a similar fast-casual experience, but there is more of an emphasis on quality and customer service.
Many Jersey Mike’s locations have a more “deli” vibe, with a focus on fresh ingredients and a friendly, welcoming atmosphere. The chain also offers catering services for larger events, which adds another layer of service compared to Subway.
Conclusion
While both Subway and Jersey Mike’s are popular sandwich chains that cater to similar customer needs, they have significant differences in terms of their menu offerings, ingredient quality, preparation style, pricing, and overall dining experience. Subway is known for its vast menu, affordability, and customization options, while Jersey Mike’s distinguishes itself with premium ingredients, fresh slicing, and a more traditional deli experience.
Ultimately, your choice between the two will depend on what you’re looking for in a sandwich. If you prioritize value and speed, Subway might be the better choice. But if you’re seeking a premium sub made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and a more traditional deli experience, Jersey Mike’s is likely the better option.
Related topics:
- How Much Does Jersey Mike Franchise Make
- How Much Does A Papa John’s Franchise Owner Make?
- What Is The Cost of A Domino’s Franchise?